Wheels
The case of the shaking brakes

BY JAMES HALDERMAN
For Wheels

Wheels: Herman writes, “I have a 2000 Kia Sportage with a brake problem. The car has about 90,000 miles on it. When you apply the brakes, the car shakes really bad. I assumed the brakes needed to be replaced. I changed the front pads. There was not much left of the front brake pads. The car still shook when the brakes where applied. So I assumed the rear brakes needed replacing. The rear brakes are shoes. I took off the drums and found the shoes were not worn very much. So I’m puzzled as to what the problem is. A friend said the rear drums needed turned. I took the drums to get them turned and found out the drums were over the diameter to be turned. I talked to the auto parts guys to see if he could come up with a solution. His solution was to adjust the brakes to travel further out. My question is: Could the drums be too far out of tolerance, causing the shoe to not make contact with the drums? The steering wheel does not shake when the brakes are applied.”
Halderman: The shaking when the brakes are applied indicates one of several possible causes including:
1. If the front brake rotors were warped, then the steering wheel would shake, but because you indicated that this was not occurring, this fault can be eliminated.
2. If the front rotors had a variation in thickness, then the whole vehicle will shake when the brakes are applied. If the problem is most noticeable when braking at higher speeds, this is the most likely cause. While you could have the rotors machined, I would suggest simply replacing them, considering the high mileage and the possibility of rust damage.
3. If the entire vehicle shakes, the rear drums could be out-of-round. Again, replacement drums would be required in your case.
A quick and easy test to see if the problem is due to the front or rear wheel brakes is to drive on a road without traffic at highway speed and apply the parking brake. If the vehicle shakes, the rear brakes are the cause. If the vehicle does not shake, this test confirms that the front brakes (rotors) are the cause.

Wheels: Kent writes, “I have a 2005 Ford Freestar SEL with 18,000 miles. When the motor is cold, the engine has a noise that sounds like a soft diesel motor. This is only noticeable when at idle, in or out of gear, but not when driving. Also, once the motor gets to operating temperature, the diesel-like noise goes away. Do I have another problem with my particular engine?”
Halderman: The noise you are hearing, while it may be a concern, is likely normal. The vehicle manufacturers are trying to reduce internal engine friction. One way manufacturers improve fuel economy is to reduce piston side loading. While it makes the engine quieter when cold, it also increases internal friction, which hurts fuel economy. I doubt you have any concerns with your engine. To be sure, try to drive a similar vehicle and see if the same noise is heard.
James D. Halderman is an ASE-certified master technician. Submit your automotive care questions to Halderman via e-mail at jhalderman2@juno.com.
, or write him in care of: Wheels, Marketing Publications Department, Dayton Daily News, 45 S. Ludlow St., Dayton OH 45402.


Appeared in April 1, 2006 issue of Wheels, a product of the Dayton Daily News